Neighborhood watch shooting victim found guilty in sex crimes case

Posted at 4:17 PM, Mar 29, 2012
and last updated 2012-03-30 16:37:59-04

SALT LAKE CITY -- David Serbeck, the man paralyzed in a neighborhood watch shooting in Bluffdale, was convicted on three counts of unlawful sexual conduct Thursday after being found guilty by the jury.

The jury deliberated for about two hours before coming back with the guilty verdict.

Serbeck was accused of carrying on a sexual relationship with a 16 or 17-year-old girl. Sentencing for the three third-degree felonies could carry a penalty of 15 years in prison.
Serbeck was immediately put in handcuffs and placed into custody by order of the judge. His sentencing will take place in May.

Serbeck maintained his innocence from the beginning and denied everything that the prosecution claimed.

While the jury was deliberating, FOX 13 interviewed the victim.

"I hope now that any other girls that were out there, who were, you know, victimized by this man, by Dave, I hope now they have some closure themselves," she said.

Serbeck's attorney says that his client never wavered in regards to his innocence in the sex abuse claims.

"He didn't do it. Our defense was simply that, that he didn't do what he was accused of and he maintained that from the first day I met him through today and I have no reason to doubt it," said Serbeck's attorney

On Wednesday, Serbeck sat quietly as the now 23-year-old woman testified about the sexual relationship she claims to have had with him in 2007.

The woman told the jury she first met Serbeck when she was 16. She went to his house several times to look at snakes that he owned. She told the jury she had “a connection with him” about suffering from post traumatic stress disorder and depression.

We were sitting on the couch and, later on, after talking a little more a kiss was slipped in,” she told the jury.

“By who?” prosecutor Alicia Cook asked her.

“It just kind of happened I guess,” she replied. “It’s hard to explain.”

The woman claimed she was “shocked, embarrassed, sick” by the kiss. But she continued to text message him and it escalated to a sexual relationship. She told the jury they had sex three times in the summer of 2007.

Under cross-examination, Berrett asked if she was so scared and shocked, why did she continue to have any contact with Serbeck?

“Because at the same time I felt that he kind of needed someone to talk to, needed someone there for him because of everything else he told me,” she replied.

The woman claims the relationship became known when a friend found nude pictures she had taken with her cell phone and told her father. Serbeck denied anything at the time, she said on the witness stand.

The woman, who has filed a civil lawsuit against Serbeck, spoke to him again briefly in 2009. Then she went to police after he was shot. She acknowledged under cross-examination that she tried to help Reggie Campos’ defense team and that her attorney represented Campos during his criminal trial.

Campos was convicted of attempted murder and is serving time in the Utah State Prison. In an interview with FOX 13 from prison last year, Campos defended his actions.

“I know my daughter and her friends are safe and I know other girls are safe and if I have to do a little time for that then that’s the price I have to pay,” he said.

On Wednesday, another woman came forward to accuse Serbeck of sexual impropriety.

Lacey Bazinet alleged Serbeck sexually abused her when she was 15 years old.  She said the statute of limitations have run out for her to bring charges against Serbeck, but she may take the stand for the prosecution in this case.

“I want him to serve time. I don’t think it’s right he should get away with any of this. He’s gotten away with it for 12 years that I know of and that’s just me,” Bazinet told FOX 13. “He could have had victims before then.”

Salt Lake County prosecutors acknowledged that she had been interviewed by law enforcement, but no charges were ever filed. Serbeck’s defense attorney refused to address the woman’s claims.