Man impregnates biological daughter given up for adoption as an infant

Posted at 10:01 AM, Feb 05, 2018
and last updated 2018-02-05 12:01:24-05

KNIGHTDALE, N.C. - The biological mother of a young woman who police said developed a sexual relationship with her biological father has a warning for parents of adopted children.

She told WTVR that if their child wants to reunite with their biological parents, they should be in therapy when they reunite because the feelings that come up during the reunion can get confused with something else.

Pictures she provided to WTVR show her daughter and ex-husband posing with their new baby.

Katie and Steven Pladl

Twenty-year-old Katie Pladl is 42-year-old Steven Pladl's biological daughter.

"This is a pretty unique set of facts I would say," legal analyst Todd Stone said.

North Carolina investigators arrested the couple, and both face charges related to incest and will be extradited back to Henrico, Virginia, where they allegedly first developed a sexual relationship.

"It's a Class 5 felony if that occurs in Virginia and that means you can get up to 10 years in prison," Stone said about the charges.

Steven Pladl's ex-wife said she was 17 and he was 22 when they had Katie and gave her up for adoption.

But, when Katie reached the age of 18, she located her biological parents to develop a relationship.

Katie and Steven Pladl

She ultimately moved in with the couple for a couple of months at their home and called the pair mom and dad, according to her biological mom.

But Katie's mom ultimately moved out when the couple opted to separate.

She said she had no idea a sexual relationship started between her ex-husband and her daughter until she read one of her other daughter's journals where she found drawings of Katie being pregnant and found her daughter had written that her father was making her call Katie step-mom.

At that point, she said she took out protective orders against Steven, so he could not go near her or their two younger daughters.

She believes her ex-husband brainwashed and manipulated Katie.

Katie moved in with her moved in biological parents at this Henrico home

Stone said the judge who hears the case will have some tough choices to make.

"A judge will have an opportunity to decide whether this statue makes this conduct illegal because of moral and religious ideas or science and increased chance of birth defects,” Stone said. “What should the penalty really be for people who are both adults and consenting to a sexual relationship even though it's illegal in Virginia and most other places?"

To that point, Stone said incest is not illegal everywhere. In fact, it's not against the law in New Jersey, and he said in some countries it is perfectly acceptable, but in Virginia, that's not the case.