Curtis, Thorpe spar in debate for Utah's 3rd Congressional District

Posted at 5:48 PM, Oct 15, 2020
and last updated 2020-10-16 00:22:00-04

SALT LAKE CITY — The leading candidates for Utah's 3rd Congressional District engaged in a sometimes tense debate over issues facing voters.

Republican incumbent Congressman John Curtis and his Democratic challenger, Devin Thorpe, pledged to be bipartisan. (In fact, Curtis said he used to be a Democrat and Thorpe said he used to be a Republican.)

But where the two found agreement over some things like rural needs and some regulation of social media companies, they also had some terse exchanges as Thorpe repeatedly tried to go after Curtis for his record in Washington, D.C.

"I believe that climate’s changing and man’s having an influence over it," Curtis said when asked about the subject of climate change and his bills to address environmental issues.

"I’m very troubled by the congressman’s record on voting. Yes, he’s put forward some legislation he mentioned, but in fact, he’s never voted for a bill that’s designed to reduce carbon emissions," Thorpe said in his response.

Curtis pushed back.

"Devin, I give you a little challenge to find one of those bills that you’re referring to that had more than two or three Republican co-sponsors," the congressman said of Democrat-led climate bills that did not include GOP input.

Later in the debate Thorpe also tried to press Curtis on GOP efforts to repeal the Affordable Care Act. Curtis, who is known as a moderate in Congress, swatted it away.

"The ship has sailed, Republicans tried to repeal. It was unsuccessful. That question is off the table and to be more successful, no, not without a replacement," Curtis said. "It is an absolute fabrication and lie and anybody that says it is lying or believe someone is lying, that somehow Republicans don’t to protect pre-existing conditions or somehow I have voted to remove pre-existing conditions."

"I am so grateful the congressman is committed to protecting pre-existing conditions because he voted for HR692, which specifically allowed states to allow insurance companies to disallow pre-existing conditions," Thorpe countered.

Curtis rebuked his opponent for it.

"Devin, if you want to be the type of politician that you say you want to be, you cannot cherry pick a bill, go down deep inside and find one provision that I opposed that had tons of bad provisions and somehow make the conclusion you know how i feel about an issue," he said.

The Utah Debate Commission's poll that set the threshold for participation finds Curtis with a 30-point margin over Thorpe in the race. The 3rd Congressional District is arguably one of the most conservative in America, stretching from deep-red Utah County down to San Juan County (which has become a little more purple).

"We are in a difficult district. But I am not running as a protest candidate," Thorpe told reporters afterward. "I’m not running to raise issues. I am running to be the congressman. I am convinced we can do that."

Curtis insisted he was not resting easy.

"I think I like to define campaigning as working in the district and working for the district and not necessarily pounding in signs," he said.

Watch the debate here: