SALT LAKE CITY — A former manager for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints' investment arm who filed a whistleblower complaint with the Internal Revenue Service has given a sworn declaration in James Huntsman's high-profile fraud lawsuit against the faith.
David Nielsen's statement was included in a late night court filing by Huntsman, who alleges the Latter-day Saint church used tithing money for improper purposes, including funding downtown's City Creek Center project. Huntsman is the brother of former Utah governor Jon Huntsman Jr. and a member of the wealthy family.
Huntsman's legal team filed a response to the Church's request to dismiss the lawsuit.
"The Church’s present summary judgment motion is nothing more than its latest calculated effort to deceive the public and distort the facts. More specifically, to support its untenable position that tithing funds were not solicited through fraudulent means, the Church has painted a wildly-complex narrative, which is clearly intended to further obfuscate the truth about where tithing monies went," Huntsman's attorney, David Jonelis, wrote in the filing.
Nielsen filed an IRS complaint related to his former position as a senior portfolio manager for Ensign Peak Advisors, a multi-billion dollar investment arm of the Church. Nielen accused the Latter-day Saint church of pocketing billions instead of spending it on charitable purposes.
"According to what the senior leadership of EPA informed me, in 1997 EPA was formed and was seeded with tithing money from the Church," Nielsen wrote in his sworn statement in Huntsman's lawsuit. "During my employment at EPA, EPA’s senior leadership and other EPA employees referred to and revered all funds of EPA as 'tithing' money, regardless of whether they were referring to principal or earnings on that principal. In addition, during my time at EPA, tithing donations from the Church’s members were commingled with earnings that EPA had made. Every penny was referred to as the 'widow’s mite.'"
Huntsman's attorneys seize on this declaration to make their case that the Church defrauded him by spending tithing dollars for improper uses, but he acknowledged he stopped giving to the faith in 2015, years before the lawsuit was filed.
"While it is true that I stopped paying tithings in or around 2015 because I became I became disillusioned with the Church’s doctrines (including its support of polygamy and its open disdain for members of the LGBTQ community), I never had any intention of asking for my tithings back at that time," Huntsman wrote in a declaration filed with the court. "Rather, it was only in 2019, after I learned of the facts contained in David Nielsen’s IRS whistleblower complaint, and after I realized for the first time in my life that the Church had lied to me about where my tithing donations had gone, that I quietly asked for my tithing donations back on December 21, 2020."
A judge has scheduled a hearing in Los Angeles later this month, where the Church has asked him to rule on the future of the lawsuit.
Read Huntsman's motion to dismiss here:
Read David Nielsen's declaration here:
Read James Huntsman's declaration here: